Tankless water heaters are known for their energy efficiency and on-demand hot water delivery. However, if your unit is too large, you might spend money on unused heated water. More extensive models come with higher upfront costs, possibly leading to unnecessary expenses. Homeowners must thus select the right-sized water heater to optimize efficiency and cost-effectiveness.

When sizing a tankless water heater, a plumber assesses two key factors: flow rate and temperature rise. Flow rate measures the volume of water passing through a fixture per minute during usage, while temperature rise accounts for the difference between incoming water temperature and the desired output temperature. The cumulative flow rates of all fixtures intended for simultaneous use determine the required flow rate for the new water heater unit.

Despite these considerations, a tankless water heater might still be oversized. Here are key indicators that your tankless water heater is too large for your home.

1. Inconsistent Water Temperature

One clear sign of an oversized tankless water heater is inconsistent water temperature. When the unit is too large, it struggles to modulate the heat output effectively, leading to erratic temperature fluctuation during usage. The oversized unit will heat water quickly and may overshoot the target. This rapid heating and overshooting results in bursts of hot water, followed by a sudden drop in the temperature. You may have noticed this when in the shower. Does the water temperature unexpectedly shoot from comfortably warm to uncomfortably hot or cold? An oversized water heater is the culprit behind that inconsistency.

Oversized units find it challenging to maintain a steady flow of hot water when the demand varies. If it is too big, the water heater may need help adapting to the flow rate changes, leading to uneven temperatures during simultaneous water usage in different areas of your home. Also, these tankless water heaters modulate the heat output based on the demand for hot water. When the unit is too large, it may fail to modulate efficiently. This is a critical indicator that your unit may be too big for your household needs. Addressing the issue is essential not only for improved comfort but also for your family’s safety.

2. Frequent Cycling on and Off

Frequent cycling on and off, also known as short cycling, indicates that your tankless water heater is too big for your household needs. This phenomenon occurs when the unit rapidly heats water to the desired temperature, causing it to shut off quickly and then restart another cycle shortly after. Instead of running sustainably to meet steady demand, the heater will quickly reach the desired water temperature and shut off.

Short cycling not only leads to discomfort but also significantly contributes to increased wear and tear on the various components of the water heater. The frequent start-stop cycles can stress critical components like the heating elements of the heat exchanger. Over time, this heightened stress may result in premature component failure, leading to a demand for repair or replacement. The components like relay switches, sensors, or electronic controls are also prone to malfunction when exposed to frequent short cycles and rapid temperature changes. Addressing the issue of short cycling is essential to ensure the longevity of your unit and provide a reliable hot water supply.

3. Higher Energy Bills

Contrary to energy savings expectations with tankless water heaters, an oversized unit can lead to higher energy bills. When a water heater is oversized, it can lead to inefficiencies and increased energy consumption, impacting your monthly utility costs. Frequent short cycling is done every day in oversized units as it tries to meet the quick heating demands. This constant cycling can increase energy usage as the unit expends energy to start up repeatedly rather than running more consistently at a lower, steady rate.

The tankless water heater design emphasizes efficiency by heating water only when needed. However, an oversized unit may need help to modulate its heat output effectively, leading to efficient energy utilization. The energy consumed during unnecessary heating cycles contributes to higher overall energy bills. Also, when the water heater has a larger heating capacity than necessary for your household’s demand, it heats water beyond what is needed. This excessive heating increases energy load, negatively impacting your utility expenses.

While the upfront cost of an oversized tankless water heater may be higher, the long-term costs associated with increased energy bills can be even more significant. Over time, the cumulative effect of inefficient energy usage can outweigh any potential benefits from the initial investment in a larger unit.

4. Flow Rate Mismatch

An oversized unit can show itself when there is a significant mismatch between the heater’s flow rate capacity and your actual water demand. If the unit is designed for a higher flow rate than your household needs, it might need help maintaining a consistent hot water pressure. This mismatch can lead to temperature fluctuations, especially during times of lower demand, making it challenging for the heater to adapt to changes in flow rate. The water pressure fluctuations become particularly noticeable during simultaneous water usage in different home areas, like running multiple showers or appliances.

Lower flow rates during periods of low demand can cause water stagnation within the heat exchanger. Stagnant water allows mineral deposits, such as lime scale, to accumulate, reducing the heat exchanger’s efficiency and affecting the water heater’s overall performance. Addressing this flow rate mismatch requires assessing your water usage patterns and considering resizing the unit to suit you better.

5. Shorter Lifespan

When a tankless water heater is too big for your needs, it has trouble adjusting its heat output to match what you use. This process strains essential parts like the burner and controls, wearing them out faster and risking the overall reliability of the unit. For a longer-lasting water heater, ensure it’s the right size for your household, maintain regular maintenance, and follow the manufacturer’s recommendations. Matching the unit to your hot water needs and fixing any efficiency issues can help it last longer and work better.

If you notice any or several of the above signs, it is very important to call your plumber and have them offer you a solution for the correct tankless water heater size for your home. On Time Experts is your one-stop solution for all your heating, cooling, plumbing, and filtration needs in Garland, Dallas, and the surrounding area. We’ve covered you, from addressing HVAC faults to tackling drain clogs, toilet blockages, and more. Enjoy same-day service and complete satisfaction with our HVAC services, making us stand out for our friendly and experienced approach. Count on us for fast resolutions in plumbing emergencies, from blocked toilets to water heater installations. Need advice on new plumbing fittings? We provide tailored recommendations to suit your needs and budget. Contact On Time Experts today and testify to our efficient and reliable solutions for all your home service needs.

company icon